Tuesday, June 22, 2021
Top 3 Exercises to Avoid at the Gym. Part 2: Lateral Deltoid Raise
The lateral deltoid raise has been around since the beginning of weight training. Which is one of the reasons I don't recommend it. Weight training has its roots in bodybuilding and strongman circus shows. Some of the exercises that come from this era are focused on muscular development for the sake of muscular development. As such the premise is to "isolate" a specific muscle. In terms of function, however, it needs to be stated that MUSCLES NEVER WORK IN ISOLATION.
The above picture, taken from Fitnesstogether.com, shows the exercise performed to 90 degrees, as it is usually performed in the gym. If you are confused, think of this exercise relative to how your shoulder functions. The shoulder joint has the greatest range of motion of any joint in the human body. Given that most of our musculoskeletal aches and pains stem from a lack of movement and inactivity, wouldn't it make sense to use our joints to the greatest degree possible without strain? The rationale for stoppping at shoulder height is based on how much the deltoid muscle is being activated as the weight is lifted. Past 90 degrees, the deltoid muscle activation starts to derease and the trapezius muscle activation starts to increase. But as I stated earler, muscles never work in isolation in real life movements and activities. So why in the world would you train it to? And why not train the trapezius AND the deltoid with one exercise?
To be clear, I am recommending to go all the way up with this exercise, as seen in this photo taken from Muscle and Fitness website. I have no research to point to that suggests that this exercise performed to 90 degrees leads to shoulder injury. But I have seen numerous patients who have had shoulder problems, AND they are currently doing this exercise to 90 degrees, AND they don't want to stop wieght training. In every case, getting the patient to go to a full range of motion lateral raise, with lighter weights, has helped.
Thursday, May 13, 2021
Top 3 exercises to avoid at the gym : Part 1
Are you heading back to the gym after a long layoff? You are in good company. It's time to turn our Covid bods into beach bods.
Which makes this a good time to review Dr. Schafer's list of most common gym exercises to avoid. Let's dive right in.
#1 Seated leg press
To be clear, I am not saying that everyone who goes near this machine will wreck their back permanently. But I have observed it to be a major factor in people who like to weight train, but have periodic problems with their back. It seems like a safe exercise because you are seated. But that is exactly what is wrong with it. This exercise tries to replicate a squatting motion without having the person stand. If you turn the image 45 degrees clockwise and imagine the person has her feet on the floor, you start to get the idea of the problem.
To be lifting any weight withe the spine is this position is less than ideal. This obviously does not resemble a squat. The person invariably rounds their low back in order to perform the lift. This changes the curvature of the lumbar spine to a more flexed position, which is commonly associated with intervertebral disc injury. Also, in this position, the low back muscles are stretched out. They remain in this position during the entire motion. Muscles are known to be stronger when they get shorter. To have them lengthened throughout this movement sets them up for fatigue and failure. Skip this one and do some dumbell deadlifts instead. Stay with lighter weights if you are concerned about straining your back.
To be continued....
Tuesday, March 2, 2021
Top 5 Things To Avoid When Stretching
To say that I often get asked about stretches is an understatement. About half
of my patients are already stretching, and they want more. But should they be? Do they need more? Here
are the most common things to avoid.
1. DON'T stretch a muscle that doesn't need stretching. How do you know if it
needs stretching? In reality, it takes a trained eye. The best method is to find
out which, if any, muscles are shortened. Is the range of motion in the
associated joint less than what it should be? Is it less than the other side? If
you have a muscle that is overused, it may feel tight. But daily stretching of a
chronically overused muscle does not solve the problem. Its best to figure out
why its overused, and to try to change your behaviors in some way to allow it to
heal.
2. DON'T assume that if a muscle feels tight or taught, it should be
stretched. Just because a muscle FEELS tight, does not automatically mean that
it is SHORT. You also need to compare this to the overall genetics of the
person. Are they flexible overall? Is there right hamstring worse than their
left? What about compared to hp flexors? There is a wide range of normal for how
flexible someone is overall. Not everyone needs to stretch everything all of the
time.
3. DON'T hold your breath while stretching. I don't have much research to
back this up. But I do have personal and professional observation. In my
observations, stretching never seems to improve muscle length if the person is
holding their breath. I suspect it is because when you hold your breath, you are
telling your body "this is an extreme position, don't bother getting used to
it". By breathing through the entire stretch, you are signalling to your body
that the new muscle length position is OK, and it will not cause harm.
4. DON'T stretch a muscle 10 times a day or more. I see this mostly with patients with
neck an upper back pain. Especially if the pain is one sided. The patient is
stretching their neck to one side only numerous times a day, in an effort to
stretch an overused, but not shortened, muscle. This patient usually asks for
more stretches. But more stretching will not solve the problem that is causing
their pain.
5. DON'T bounce. This was a thing. I think in the 1970's it was
common. I see it rarely, but It still concerns me when I do see it. Technically
it's called ballistic stretching and their is research to suggest it increased
your chancs for straining the muscle. I don't think you want that.
www.schaferchiropractic.com
Thursday, September 5, 2019
What does it mean if I have one leg longer than the other?
A recent visit to my local seamstress got me thinking about leg length difference. She seemed (no pun intended) surprised when I objected to her measuring each leg individually, and cutting the pant lengths according to those measurements. I think there is a large misunderstanding about leg length difference. What does it really mean?
"Oh, and I have one leg longer than the other." is something I have been told many times by new patients. They are all eager to relay to me what previous chiropractors have told them, and most of this information IS helpful. Yet I sense that many of them don't really grasp what it means, because they appear surprised when I explain it.
"Unequal leg length is usually an indicator that the pelvis is tilted or twisted, and an adjustment is needed to make them equal" is my usual explanation. I have seen some chiropractors and physical therapists try to account for the leg length discrepancy by giving the patient a heel lift. This is usually a bad idea, as it is only perpetuating the misalignment.
However, there is occasionally a patient who actually has one leg longer than the other. I have seen this only twice in my 20 year career. Both times the person had a fracture of one of the long bones in the leg. One patient had fractured the femur during childhood, effectively halting the growth in that leg. The other one had shattered both the tibia and the fibula (lower leg bones) in an auto accident, and the surgeon was unsuccessful in recreating the pre-accident leg length.
There are conflicting opinions on how to measure leg length. Some involve a tape measure. Some involve a full lower body x-ray. My method is a bit more simple. If I can't get the legs to even out by spinal, pelvic, and limb adjustment, then there is a good chance they are just different lengths. But like I said, I have seen this only twice in twenty years.
Before adjustment:
After adjustment:
Misalignment of the pelvis truly is common, and is often due to:
-Sleeping on your stomach (This torques the torso considerably, because you need to do so in order to breathe.)
-Sitting with one foot tucked under your pelvis (see photo)
-Always crossing one leg over the other when sitting.
-A previous injury to a leg or foot. This will often result in the person hiking up the pelvis on the side of pain, so as to not to put weight on that limb.
So the next time you are getting fitted for pants, and the seamstress says that they want to sew one pant leg longer, because they measured one leg longer than the other, tell the seamstress to split the difference. You are going to see your chiropractor.
"Oh, and I have one leg longer than the other." is something I have been told many times by new patients. They are all eager to relay to me what previous chiropractors have told them, and most of this information IS helpful. Yet I sense that many of them don't really grasp what it means, because they appear surprised when I explain it.
"Unequal leg length is usually an indicator that the pelvis is tilted or twisted, and an adjustment is needed to make them equal" is my usual explanation. I have seen some chiropractors and physical therapists try to account for the leg length discrepancy by giving the patient a heel lift. This is usually a bad idea, as it is only perpetuating the misalignment.
However, there is occasionally a patient who actually has one leg longer than the other. I have seen this only twice in my 20 year career. Both times the person had a fracture of one of the long bones in the leg. One patient had fractured the femur during childhood, effectively halting the growth in that leg. The other one had shattered both the tibia and the fibula (lower leg bones) in an auto accident, and the surgeon was unsuccessful in recreating the pre-accident leg length.
There are conflicting opinions on how to measure leg length. Some involve a tape measure. Some involve a full lower body x-ray. My method is a bit more simple. If I can't get the legs to even out by spinal, pelvic, and limb adjustment, then there is a good chance they are just different lengths. But like I said, I have seen this only twice in twenty years.
Before adjustment:
After adjustment:
Misalignment of the pelvis truly is common, and is often due to:
-Sleeping on your stomach (This torques the torso considerably, because you need to do so in order to breathe.)
-Sitting with one foot tucked under your pelvis (see photo)
-Always crossing one leg over the other when sitting.
-A previous injury to a leg or foot. This will often result in the person hiking up the pelvis on the side of pain, so as to not to put weight on that limb.
So the next time you are getting fitted for pants, and the seamstress says that they want to sew one pant leg longer, because they measured one leg longer than the other, tell the seamstress to split the difference. You are going to see your chiropractor.
Wednesday, August 28, 2019
Foot Pain AND Low Back Pain? Try this simple stretch.
Many of my patients are surprised to find out that Chiropractic care can help those with foot and ankle pain. Common problems such as plantar fasciitis, sprained ankles, and achilles tendonitis, often improve with foot adjustments and home exercises. Sometimes orthotics or inserts can help as well. Yes many chiropractors are taught adjustments for just about any joint in your body, so if you are unsure, please ask.
Whats even more surprising for some people is how their foot pain is related to their low back pain. To be clear, I am not talking about a pinched nerve in the low back creating pain in the foot. That is possible. But even more common is when systems of muscles develop a weak link.
One common example is when muscles behind the knee become short and tight. This is not the same as a tight hamstring. There is a system of muscles that starts at the bottom of the feet, then goes to the calf muscles, then to the hamstring muscles, then to the gluteal muscles, then to the low back, then upper back, then neck. Keep in mind that muscles NEVER work in isolation. They have to work in systems. So to isolate them for therapeutic purposes is counterproductive. There is often no pain behind the knee when this happens, so you likely don't know that you have it. This tight and short area of muscles and fascia are responsible for some people's achilles tendonitis, or plantar fasciitis, or gluteal pain, or low back pain. The weak link behind the knee is making the other painful areas work harder.
But stretching this area effectively is the key.
You are probably thinking "Why am I not touching my toes?" It's because we are trying to stretch the muscles behind the knee, not the hamstrings! Yes the hamstrings are part of the problem, but so are the gastrocnemius, plantaris and popliteus muscles. Think of WHY this area is tight to begin with. It is because we sit too much. We live in a culture where it is often necessary to sit too much, and that is NOT going to change. The sitting position puts the knees in a bent position. This is why the muscles in this area shorten and become tight. The muscles at the top of the leg, where the hamstrings start, are NOT shortened in this sitting position. Once again, to be clear, you probably don't have pain behind the knee. But trying to stretch that area is often painful, and that is exactly why we DON'T like to do it.
Don't get too aggressive with the height of the foot while stretching this area. Stay with a low chair, ottoman, or the bottom stair of a staircase. Use the railing of the staircase, or another chair for stability. DON'T bend the supporting knee. DON'T twist out the foot of the supporting leg. DO stand tall and stick your chest out and your butt out slightly. And most importantly, let it relax and BREATHE.
This one stretch alone is a good start to resolving the problem, but often it is not enough. Adjustments and more corrective exercises are usually needed for long term success.
Whats even more surprising for some people is how their foot pain is related to their low back pain. To be clear, I am not talking about a pinched nerve in the low back creating pain in the foot. That is possible. But even more common is when systems of muscles develop a weak link.
One common example is when muscles behind the knee become short and tight. This is not the same as a tight hamstring. There is a system of muscles that starts at the bottom of the feet, then goes to the calf muscles, then to the hamstring muscles, then to the gluteal muscles, then to the low back, then upper back, then neck. Keep in mind that muscles NEVER work in isolation. They have to work in systems. So to isolate them for therapeutic purposes is counterproductive. There is often no pain behind the knee when this happens, so you likely don't know that you have it. This tight and short area of muscles and fascia are responsible for some people's achilles tendonitis, or plantar fasciitis, or gluteal pain, or low back pain. The weak link behind the knee is making the other painful areas work harder.
But stretching this area effectively is the key.
You are probably thinking "Why am I not touching my toes?" It's because we are trying to stretch the muscles behind the knee, not the hamstrings! Yes the hamstrings are part of the problem, but so are the gastrocnemius, plantaris and popliteus muscles. Think of WHY this area is tight to begin with. It is because we sit too much. We live in a culture where it is often necessary to sit too much, and that is NOT going to change. The sitting position puts the knees in a bent position. This is why the muscles in this area shorten and become tight. The muscles at the top of the leg, where the hamstrings start, are NOT shortened in this sitting position. Once again, to be clear, you probably don't have pain behind the knee. But trying to stretch that area is often painful, and that is exactly why we DON'T like to do it.
Don't get too aggressive with the height of the foot while stretching this area. Stay with a low chair, ottoman, or the bottom stair of a staircase. Use the railing of the staircase, or another chair for stability. DON'T bend the supporting knee. DON'T twist out the foot of the supporting leg. DO stand tall and stick your chest out and your butt out slightly. And most importantly, let it relax and BREATHE.
This one stretch alone is a good start to resolving the problem, but often it is not enough. Adjustments and more corrective exercises are usually needed for long term success.
Wednesday, June 26, 2019
The Most Common Postural Problem ( that you've probably never heard of )
Many of my patients have alternating symptoms of neck pain, shoulder pain and low back pain. They come to my office for the symptom that is currently the worst, and tend to downplay the symptoms that are currently minimal. They don't realize that all of the symptoms are related to the same dysfunction. Their spine is too straight.
When you look at a spine from the front, you want it to be straight (see pic below). But if you do see curvatures here, it is called scoliosis.
When you look at a spine from the side, there are normal curvatures. In the picture below the person is facing right. The forward curve to the neck and low back are called lordosis. The backward curve of the upper back is called a kyphosis. The pelvis tilts forward slightly as well. These are all natural and necessary for normal pain free function. These curvatures, along with the intervertebral discs, help to provide normal movement as well as shock absorption.
Many of us have lost touch with our bodies to the point where WHAT WE THINK is straight and upright really IS NOT. This is most common in those that have a job which requires them to sit. Sitting usually tilts the pelvis back, slouches the low back, and gives our upper body a slight forward lean. With good intentions, many of us try to correct this posture. But instead of tilting the pelvis to initiate the change, we straighten our upper backs. This eliminates the natural and necessary kyphotic curvature.
This dysfunction results in elongated low back and neck muscles that can't do their job. Muscles get weaker as they get longer. They tend to fatigue more quickly. This position also puts more pressure on the intervertebral discs of the neck and low back. So not only can your muscles hurt, but your joints as well. The muscles around the shoulder blades (scapulae) also become painful because the joint surfaces don't match up. The scapulae have a concave underside to them, which glides along the ribcage. The backside of the ribcage should be convex to match the surface, as in the picture below. But with a flat back, it is not. As the scapulae are pulled away from the ribcage, the muscles are elongated. Again, an elongated muscle is weaker, and fatigues more quickly.
Flat back posture also makes it difficult to take in a full breath, as the ribcage cannot fully spread out like it should. Altered breathing patterns result in fatigue of the muscles of the neck and low back, as these are relied upon more often. This spinal flattening plus a slight pitch forward is the most common postural problem I see in the office today. I know what you are thinking - "What can I do about it?" Stay tuned. You get your answer in my next blog.
When you look at a spine from the front, you want it to be straight (see pic below). But if you do see curvatures here, it is called scoliosis.
When you look at a spine from the side, there are normal curvatures. In the picture below the person is facing right. The forward curve to the neck and low back are called lordosis. The backward curve of the upper back is called a kyphosis. The pelvis tilts forward slightly as well. These are all natural and necessary for normal pain free function. These curvatures, along with the intervertebral discs, help to provide normal movement as well as shock absorption.
Many of us have lost touch with our bodies to the point where WHAT WE THINK is straight and upright really IS NOT. This is most common in those that have a job which requires them to sit. Sitting usually tilts the pelvis back, slouches the low back, and gives our upper body a slight forward lean. With good intentions, many of us try to correct this posture. But instead of tilting the pelvis to initiate the change, we straighten our upper backs. This eliminates the natural and necessary kyphotic curvature.
This dysfunction results in elongated low back and neck muscles that can't do their job. Muscles get weaker as they get longer. They tend to fatigue more quickly. This position also puts more pressure on the intervertebral discs of the neck and low back. So not only can your muscles hurt, but your joints as well. The muscles around the shoulder blades (scapulae) also become painful because the joint surfaces don't match up. The scapulae have a concave underside to them, which glides along the ribcage. The backside of the ribcage should be convex to match the surface, as in the picture below. But with a flat back, it is not. As the scapulae are pulled away from the ribcage, the muscles are elongated. Again, an elongated muscle is weaker, and fatigues more quickly.
Flat back posture also makes it difficult to take in a full breath, as the ribcage cannot fully spread out like it should. Altered breathing patterns result in fatigue of the muscles of the neck and low back, as these are relied upon more often. This spinal flattening plus a slight pitch forward is the most common postural problem I see in the office today. I know what you are thinking - "What can I do about it?" Stay tuned. You get your answer in my next blog.
Tuesday, June 18, 2019
Washboard Abs vs.Strong Core
I must admit I don't have "washboard abs". I have what you would call a "two-pack" instead of a "six-pack". But is having washboard abs really the same thing as having a strong core?
To answer that question, one must first define what "core" means. I don't always agree with Wikipedia, but here is what they have to say on the matter: "Major muscles included are the pelvic floor muscles, transversus abdominis, multifidus, internal and external obliques, rectus abdominis, erector spinae (sacrospinalis) especially the longissimus thoracis, and the diaphragm. The lumbar muscles, quadratus Lumborum (deep portion), deep rotators, as well as cervical muscles, rectus capitus anterior and lateralis, longus coli may also be considered members of the core group. Minor core muscles include the latissimus dorsi, gluteus maximus, and trapezius."
So there is well over a dozen muscles listed there, even if you don't include the latissimus dorsi, gluteus maximus, and trapezius, which I do. There also a few more I would add to the list such as serratus anterior. I understand the temptation to look at what you can most readily see and identify it as the "core". But we all need to get over this idea that sit-ups, crunches, or planks are the go-to core exercises for someone trying to decrease their pain levels through core muscle development. It is my humble opinion that the world of fitness, exercise science, and physical therapy have been overly influenced by the bodybuilding. The idea that we need to "isolate" one muscle at a time is quite ridiculous. In real-life scenarios, muscles don't work in isolation. Therefore training and developing them in this way is likely to end up in pain and dysfunction. Certainly the muscles look good on bodybuilders, but these folks are not as athletic as they look. Just ask one of them to run and you will see what I mean.
Here is a link to my Youtube channel. In it you will find the three core exercises I give the most : Up Dog, Side Bridge, and Bird Dog. I explain them in the videos, and in previous blogs as well, and there is no need for redundancy. Notice that none of these three main core exercises directly targets the abdominus rectus muscle. This is because the abdominus rectus muscle is one of a dozen core muscles, and is not THE important muscle. But, of course, it is still wise to train this muscle. The best way to train them is to do "Frog Abs". This exercise, like most of my core exercises, puts you into a position and hold it for three audible breaths. The breaths are very important, and it is necessary to keep them audible for two reasons. Not doing so will lead to holding your breath, guaranteed. The second reason is because it helps to stimulate the core muscles, many of which are involved with forcible inhaling and exhaling. Passive breathing (what you are likely doing right now), does not stimulate these muscles.
Click here to see Frog Abs video.
The video posted above also shows a hip position that minimizes low back pain. The turn out of the hips fires up the gluteal muscles, so that they work in conjunction with the abdominus rectus. Otherwise it is possible that the low back muscles fire up instead of the glutes, creating low back tension. Also, the lack of movement minimizes any risk of jerking your head forward, and injuring your neck.
Doing planks can be a good core exercise as well. Yet there is one inherent problem with it. The person doing it can't see their own back. I think if they did see it they would be surprised. Most people have such a gap between the shoulder blades (scapula) and their ribcage, that you could stick your fingers in there and pick them up like a suitcase. This is a sign of weak serratus anterior. Scapular winging has other possible causes, but weak core is the most common.
I guess I can't expect too much from people. They have been taught the same core exercises for decades, and now Dr. Schafer wants to start from scratch. I get it. I don't have the washboard abs, so what do I know about core muscles, right? Well, for starters, I don't have back pain.
To answer that question, one must first define what "core" means. I don't always agree with Wikipedia, but here is what they have to say on the matter: "Major muscles included are the pelvic floor muscles, transversus abdominis, multifidus, internal and external obliques, rectus abdominis, erector spinae (sacrospinalis) especially the longissimus thoracis, and the diaphragm. The lumbar muscles, quadratus Lumborum (deep portion), deep rotators, as well as cervical muscles, rectus capitus anterior and lateralis, longus coli may also be considered members of the core group. Minor core muscles include the latissimus dorsi, gluteus maximus, and trapezius."
So there is well over a dozen muscles listed there, even if you don't include the latissimus dorsi, gluteus maximus, and trapezius, which I do. There also a few more I would add to the list such as serratus anterior. I understand the temptation to look at what you can most readily see and identify it as the "core". But we all need to get over this idea that sit-ups, crunches, or planks are the go-to core exercises for someone trying to decrease their pain levels through core muscle development. It is my humble opinion that the world of fitness, exercise science, and physical therapy have been overly influenced by the bodybuilding. The idea that we need to "isolate" one muscle at a time is quite ridiculous. In real-life scenarios, muscles don't work in isolation. Therefore training and developing them in this way is likely to end up in pain and dysfunction. Certainly the muscles look good on bodybuilders, but these folks are not as athletic as they look. Just ask one of them to run and you will see what I mean.
Here is a link to my Youtube channel. In it you will find the three core exercises I give the most : Up Dog, Side Bridge, and Bird Dog. I explain them in the videos, and in previous blogs as well, and there is no need for redundancy. Notice that none of these three main core exercises directly targets the abdominus rectus muscle. This is because the abdominus rectus muscle is one of a dozen core muscles, and is not THE important muscle. But, of course, it is still wise to train this muscle. The best way to train them is to do "Frog Abs". This exercise, like most of my core exercises, puts you into a position and hold it for three audible breaths. The breaths are very important, and it is necessary to keep them audible for two reasons. Not doing so will lead to holding your breath, guaranteed. The second reason is because it helps to stimulate the core muscles, many of which are involved with forcible inhaling and exhaling. Passive breathing (what you are likely doing right now), does not stimulate these muscles.
Click here to see Frog Abs video.
The video posted above also shows a hip position that minimizes low back pain. The turn out of the hips fires up the gluteal muscles, so that they work in conjunction with the abdominus rectus. Otherwise it is possible that the low back muscles fire up instead of the glutes, creating low back tension. Also, the lack of movement minimizes any risk of jerking your head forward, and injuring your neck.
Doing planks can be a good core exercise as well. Yet there is one inherent problem with it. The person doing it can't see their own back. I think if they did see it they would be surprised. Most people have such a gap between the shoulder blades (scapula) and their ribcage, that you could stick your fingers in there and pick them up like a suitcase. This is a sign of weak serratus anterior. Scapular winging has other possible causes, but weak core is the most common.
I guess I can't expect too much from people. They have been taught the same core exercises for decades, and now Dr. Schafer wants to start from scratch. I get it. I don't have the washboard abs, so what do I know about core muscles, right? Well, for starters, I don't have back pain.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)















